Tuesday, November 11, 2008

TWO DAVIDS VS. TWO GOLIATHS

The banners have all come down, the streets are all swept free of the confetti, and the last party has been thrown. Now comes the time to analyze the election, the blame and the credit. To be sure, a lot of the credit for the big win on the Democrat side has to go to Barack Obama and a lot of the blame for the loss has to go to John McCain. That's just the way it is, the buck stops at the top. The McCain campaign leaders (not to be confused with the RNC) have thrown Alaskan Governor Sarah Palin to the wolves. This is to be expected, they certainly don't want to take the blame themselves, after all, they're all hoping to work on another campaign in the future and that's not likely to happen if they blame themselves. Governor Palin is doing the right thing. She's defending herself while pointing out that these attacks aren't coming from McCain or the RNC. Her future, from my point of view, has to be bright, I can't picture the RNC throwing away anyone with that much star power and name recognition. On the Democrat side, everyone wants in on the credit, as can be expected. But who was really the brains behind the impossible? From everything I've seen and read, it was two relatively unknowns that brought down the the twin Goliaths of McCain and Clinton; David Plouffe and David Axlerod.

So, who are the two Davids? Let's take David Plouffe first.

David Plouffe began his political career when he went to work for Senator Tom Harkin's 1990 re-election campaign. He later worked as a state field director for Harkin's unsuccessful 1992 Presidential campaign. He then successfully managed Congressman John Olver's first re-election bid in Western Massachusetts. In 1994 Plouffe managed Delaware Attorney General Charles M. Oberly's unsuccessful campaign against Senator William V. Roth Jr.. He then worked as campaign director for the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee in 1995. In 1996, Plouffe managed Bob Torricelli's successful campaign to fill Bill Bradley's seat in the United States Senate.From 1997 to 1998 Plouffe served as Democratic leader Richard Gephardt's Deputy Chief of Staff. From 1999-2000 he worked as executive director of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, and then in 2003 he met David Axelrod and began working on Barack Obama's successful 2004 U.S. Senate Campaign and finally on Barack's Presidential bid. From the very start of Obama's campaign, Mr. Plouffe made one thing abundantly clear. There would be no drama. As Barack's campaign manager, David was the "details man", in charge of the Obama strategy to win. With every state thought out in his head and every move calculated, David Plouffe believed the only possible problem would come from either his staff acting out badly or his candidate coming across as an "angry black man". On that, he was completely correct. White America had seen it's share of passionate black presidential candidates from Rev. Jesse Jackson to Rev. Al Sharpton and they had demonstrated one thing beyond any doubt. While all were popular among black people, white people would not vote for them. Without the white vote, Mr. Plouffe concluded, Barack could not win. This theory of "no drama" was applied not just to Barack Obama, but also to his wife, his spokesmen, his supporters, campaign workers and anyone else that could be tied to Obama. David Plouffe was directly responsible for the discipline that the Obama campaign showed.

David Axelrod was Barack's Senior Political Advisor, but he could better be described as Barack's "Right Hand Man". David began his political career at age 13 handing out campaign buttons for Robert F. Kennedy. He pursued his passion for politics by attending the University of Chicago where he majored in political science. Like his counterpart, David Plouffe, he didn't graduate and went to work at the Chicago Tribune and became the City Hall Bureau Chief and a political columnist. Unhappy as just a writer, (I can relate), in 1984 he joined the campaign of US Senator Paul Simon as communications director and within weeks he was promoted to co-campaign manager. He then formed his own consulting firm, Axelrod and Associates, and was hired by Harold Washington, Chicago's first black mayor.This established his experience in working with black politicians and he later went to work on similar mayoral campaigns of blacks, including Dennis Archer in Detroit, Michael R. White in Cleveland, Anthony A. Williams in Washington, D.C., Lee P. Brown in Houston, and John F. Street in Philadelphia as well as Chicago mayor Richard M. Daley. David met Barack Obama in 1992 through a mutual friend and the two became so close that Obama consulted Axelrod before he delivered his famed 2002 anti-war speech and asked him to read drafts of his book, The Audacity of Hope. Axelrod is credited with coming up with the Caucus Strategy and post Super Tuesday Strategy that helped defeat Hillary Clinton in the primaries. I think it's fair to say that without David Axelrod, we would be looking at a Clinton or McCain Presidency.
As we assess the 2008 historic election of Barack Obama, let's all remember that Barack is not just the product of the streets of Chicago, not just the product of a caring Grandmother or the support of black people. Barack Obama is where he is today by virtue of his gift of communication and the efforts of two Davids who helped him slay two Goliaths that no one, not even me, thought he had a chance against. H.C.

9 comments:

lime said...

i have never paid much attention to the folks behind the scenes i have to admit so this was an interesting primer.

i will say obama's gift of communication is so evident and was in such stark contrast to mccain/palin. there they are trying to string together a complete sentence with a subject and a verb while obama effortlessly orates. in that case he was a giant to their midgetry.

The H.C. said...

Hey Lime,
I have to say, there have been many times that I have been very impressed with your wordplay.Your phrasing, "in that case he was a giant to their midgetry." was absolutely great! I don't think I could have worked "midgetry" into a sentence if I tried for a week! Thanks for a early morning chuckle.

lime said...

i am blushing. i do love a fitting image and extending a metaphor. glad to give you a giggle-worthy example.

Anonymous said...

Nicely done Hippie. While I don't completely agree with the complete pacifist strategy the Obama camp took on as Hillary and McCain were trying to skewer him, I can appreciate the reserve it must've took not to go militant. Using your title as context, even the Biblical giant mocked the peasant shepard boy before their altercation. Had it been me, I would've either (1) ran off sobbing like a school girl (see: Sarah Palin) or (2) been so blinded by rage that I would've attacked head on; most likely at my own peril. It took a lot for the "two Davids" to run a virtually non-combatitive contest like this, especially when opportunities to attack kept rising to the surface. I mean, no where in the campaign did I hear the words "Keating Five", "AIP", "Bristol Palin/Levi Johnston", "Richard Quinn", or "Thomas Muthee". But I'm sure the temptation was there.

The Davids did their thing this year. They were solid. Perhaps even solid enough to get Sarah Palin elected. Uh, scratch that.

The H.C. said...

Hey Dre,
Thanks. To be sure, there were two lessons to be learned in the biblical story of David and Goliath. The first being never underestimate your opponent and the second being any victory is possible if you use intelligence instead acting in a visceral fashion. I too would have liked to have heard more about the Keating Five and AIG but I'm not sure the others would have been to Obama's advantage. Quinn would have degenerated into a discussion about race which would not (in my opinion) have helped Obama with white people. I think the reason is white people didn't want to think of Barack as a black person, they wanted to just like him as a person. It's hard to explain, but white people want desperately to put the whole black/white thing behind them, the more it got brought up, the more they felt like it would be less of a healing to vote for a black man and more of a return to an uncomfortable debate (for them). I had never heard of Thomas Muthee, but I imagine they avoided it for the same reason. It would have just returned the debate back to Rev. Wrong and the race issue. Great thoughts though.

TABOR said...

Could it be the that the democratic party has finally found their own answer to Karl Rove? Economic plans and strategies will never be as important in the American political landscape as being able to manipulate voters. Sounds like things are finally balancing out. Great post on the inside workings!!

The H.C. said...

Hey Tabor,
I have to admit, I never had much admiration for Rove (and you know I'm not a hater). All he really did was use the same Rep tricks that have been used for the past several elections-play to white people's fears, rally the conservative base and tell well-off people they are not selfish for wanting to keep all their money. The only thing different in the Rove strategy was his outreach towards Hispanics based on their Catholic faith. A smart move to be sure, but not worthy of the "Boy Genius" moniker. I thought the work of David Axelrod in particular was genius because there was no template to refer to. Getting a black guy elected in America is truly a feat.
P.S. Check out my new site at steveandhc.com, we're going to be starting our show tonight and a few new vids should be up very soon. I'm hoping to have you call in once I get the radio part up and use your usual flair with words to give us sports updates. I'll keep you posted!

TABOR said...

Well I agree that Rove's tactics weren't "genius" but the way he preyed on people's fear and won elections for a retard like George Bush with non-issues such as flag-burning and gay marriage has to deserve at least a pat on the back in "Corrupt Politics 101".
As for your show, I just talked to Andy a couple hours ago and he told me about it. Unfortunately I still have no computer at my house because mine took a shit on me 2 months ago. The only time I have internet access is at work and I'll probably have to miss your first couple shows until I get a new comp. Good luck on it, I'll be thinking of you guys, and I'll be sure to check it out on youtube after it's posted. I'm still game to be a special guest on a show or 2 if I can find a ride out there.
By the way, check out my blog. I haven't been writing football pieces at all, it's mainly poetry and songs lately sprinkled with a bit of politics. I'd like to actually get a comment or two just to make it seem like someone reads my stuff. Take care and happy hunting!!

Anonymous said...

This is great - I love the two Davids and want to know more about them!